The Holy Grail — The CIA Memorial Wall, the KRYPTOS Sculpture, & the Lockerbie Tragedy — Part III: Hitting the Jackpot — NSA MEMO to Crypto Amateurs

“The fifth paragraph seems to be a yet-undefined system that may require an unusual plain-text key. This part may be unbreakable.”

CIA KRYPTOS
Sculpture Study Group
NSA Memorandum
18 November 1991

July 14, 2026A Very Special Post for Our 10th Anniversary — Over the last three decades, I have devoted much time to several distinct stories: the CIA Memorial Wall (and the associated Book of Honor), the KRYPTOS sculpture, and the Lockerbie tragedy. In my wildest dreams, I never imagined that these stories would one day converge. Follow us on Twitter: @INTEL_TODAY

RELATED POST : On This Day — KRYPTOS Sculpture Dedication Ceremony at the CIA (November 3 1990) [UPDATE : And Then Came a ‘Gigantic Mistake’… As Always!]

RELATED POST : Lockerbie 30th Anniversary — PT/35(b) : MEBO TELECOM and the Story of the MST-13 Timers

RELATED POST : CIA Annual Ceremony — 50th Anniversary of the Memorial Wall (May 17, 2024) [UPDATE — Earliest known photo of the CIA Memorial Wall]

This article is the third installment in our series. Readers may benefit from reviewing the previous articles for a better understanding of the topics discussed here.

RELATED POST : The Holy Grail — The CIA Wall, The KRYPTOS Sculpture, & The Lockerbie Tragedy

RELATED POST : The Holy Grail — The CIA Wall, The KRYPTOS Sculpture, & The Lockerbie Tragedy — Part I : Getting started [The STAR of William Francis Buckley (May 30, 1928 – June 3, 1985)]

RELATED POST : The Holy Grail — The CIA Wall, The KRYPTOS Sculpture, & The Lockerbie Tragedy — Part II : President Bill Clinton visits the CIA (January 4, 1994)

“Chance favors the prepared mind.”

Louis Pasteur

In our last post, we concluded that six stars were added to the Memorial Wall between 1985 and January 1994, including the two commemorating Bennett and Darling.

And we know that the four missing stars must be among the following fourteen:

1993 — Freddie Woodruff

1984 — One officer whose identity remains classified

1987 — Richard D. Krobock

1988 — Matthew K. Gannon

1989 — Eight stars: Robert W. Woods, six officers killed in Angola, and one officer whose identity remains classified

1992 — Barry S. Castiglione and Lawrence N. Freedman

However, without additional information, we cannot make further progress. Strangely enough, the next clue comes from Kryptos, the iconic sculpture by American artist Jim Sanborn on the grounds of Central Intelligence Agency Headquarters.

A NSA Memo about Kryptos written by George C. Dalmas (dated 18 Nov. 1991) suggests a connection with the Book of Honor!

And this NSA document — sent to KRYPTOS amateurs — provides a very rare information.

The author of this document made a small mistake. There are four stars (not five) for the year 1956. These four stars appear in the original 1974 Book of Honor, and no additional star has been added to the 1956 entry since then.

At that time of this Memo, the Book of Honor had 53 names (23 disclosed) and a simple comparison with the 1984 version implies that the 3 stars added since the 1987 ceremony are:

1984 — One officer whose identity remains classified

1985 Richard D. Krobock

1988 Matthew K. Gannon

Therefore, these three stars are necessarily stars 51, 52, and 53. Of course, I can not assert that they were added in that specific order, but logic and chronology strongly suggest that they were.

Matthew Kevin Gannon was killed in the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland, on December 21, 1988, at the age of 34. He was returning from Beirut, Lebanon. Gannon is buried at Arlington National Cemetery. The date of death engraved on his grave is off by one day. His original travel plans were to return on December 22, 1988, but he was granted permission to take an earlier flight.

About Matthew Gannon

Gannon’s father-in-law, Tom Twetten, was Director of Covert Operations at the CIA during the infamous disinformation campaign targeting Qaddafi.

This campaign began with the infamous Fuller Memorandum (May 17, 1985) and was finally exposed by Bob Woodward on October 2, 1986.

RELATED POST : On This Day — Reagan Approves Covert Arms Sales to Iran (January 17, 1986) [From the Fuller Memorandum to the Lockerbie Solution — Timeline]

Graham Fuller suggests that it would be wise to use Libya as a geopolitical punching bag (Nothing to fear and nothing to lose) while playing nice with the Iranian Ayatollah.

“The study was instrumental in persuading some top-ranking Reagan Administration policy makers to begin considering covert contacts with Iranian leaders. It eventually led to the covert sale of United States weapons to Tehran in what became the Iran-contra affair.” [New York Time, 15 February 1988]

RELATED POST : On This Day — Gaddafi Target of U.S. Disinformation (October 2 1986 — Bob Woodward) [Disinformation Goes Mainstream]

Tom Twetten was the architect of the CIA plan for the airstrikes on Tripoli on April 14, 1986.

The mysterious Swiss timer that allowed investigators to link Lockerbie to Libya appeared under highly suspicious circumstances during a coup in Togo on September 23, 1986.

During the Lockerbie trial, Tom Twetten told CBS News that he had “assured himself the two Libyans on trial were the right guys.”

Although he was speaking in cloak-and-dagger parlance, Tom Twetten came close to admitting that he had indeed framed those two Libyans.

As a wise man noted long ago, the CIA does not look for a culprit. They pick their most suitable villain.

REFERENCES

Bob Woodward. Gadhafi Target of Secret U.S. Deception Plan. Washington Post. October 2, 1986

=

The Holy Grail — The CIA Memorial Wall, the KRYPTOS Sculpture, & the Lockerbie Tragedy — Part III: Hitting the Jackpot — NSA MEMO to Crypto Amateurs

“The government’s secrecy can’t close off my mind.The last time [I called Susan Gannon], I was accused of opening my mouth too much.”

Beulah McKee
Mother of Major Charles Dennis McKee

This entry was posted in CIA Book of Honor, CIA Memorial Wall, KRYPTOS, Lockerbie, Pan Am 103. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a comment